Newmarket Hotel – St Kilda

Newmarket hotel
St Kilda

Long before I started Steak Me Out I’d ventured to the Newmarket hotel. It was a Wednesday and their cellar bar had just opened, Matt Preston, Marco Pierre White and Iain Hewitson were there, and while it didn’t make too much of a difference on the quality of the food, it made the night a little special.

With my impending move to Sydney, I was chasing that feeling one last time and ventured back. Walking in it all looked the same; the outfitting just as lovely, the dim lighting, rustic but chic architecture and the aroma of spices through the air.


I have to apologize in advance for the photos, I forgot the SD card for my camera in the computer and had to borrow my sister’s iPhone.

After a small, albeit violent, discussion with my family as to what to order, we settled on a number of various things.

For myself as a starter I go the wood barbequed corn, a fish taco and a bone marrow taco.

For the mains we decided to all order one thing and split them. I got the steak, a grass fed rib eye cooked medium (because my family are heathens and don’t eat steak right), the roast chicken, st. Louis cut pork rib and the pan grilled hapuka fillet.

To go with the never ending list of mains we also ordered some potatoes and a quinoa salad.


Soon after ordering the corn came out, and it was a bad start. Completely lack lustered, barely barbequed and smothered with a “sauce” which did nothing to help the dish. Definitely not worth $9.


The tacos on the other hand were great. The marrow was roasted well and came with a slow cooked wagyu brisket, together it was heart stoppingly rich but utterly divine, you couldn’t stop eating.

The fish was equally as fantastic if not better. Flakey fish topped with a crunchy sweet coleslaw all drizzled in a tangy jalapeño mayo to tie it all together. Perfect.


The mains came all at once, and coupled with a small table it was challenging. I’ll start with the steak, I ordered it medium so my sister and mum would eat it however it came out medium rare to rare.


Now I wasn’t annoyed, a rib eye medium rare is my bread and butter, but I need to rate based on what I’ve ordered. Aside from the cooking, the flavour was good but lacked any sort of wow factor. It was a steak you would’ve gotten for cheap at a pub. The tenderness was the same, the dry aging did it no favours either.


The rest of the mains were exquisite. The fish was out of control, the sauce, coupled with the fish and various types of seafood created a creamy and delicious flavour combination.


The chicken, a standout, all elements working harmoniously, the sauce, topping, bacon, grapes and lentils making it a pleasure to eat. The only complaint was the breast being slightly dry.


Lastly the Rib, unbelievably soft with a homemade BBQ sauce made using the slightest bit of tamarind tang with peanuts to add a textural crunch. Once again my only minor complaint is that it needed a tiny bit of chilli to hit the palate and break up the sweetness.

While the overall experience didn’t stack up to what it was, most of the food was still top quality. With the exception of the steak and corn everything was enjoyable and definitely worth returning for.


How well it’s cooked (Not well Enough) – 7.4

Flavour (Lacking) – 6.1

Tenderness (Rump like) – 6.0

Overall – 6.5

Newmarket Hotel on Urbanspoon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s